Skip to main content
Back to Rebuttal Desk
But Obama!Whataboutismmediumbut-obama-did-this

But Obama did the same thing! Why didn't you complain then?

What You Say

Whataboutism isn't a defense — it's a dodge. Even if you could find a superficial parallel, two things can be true: past presidents made mistakes AND this action is harmful now. The question isn't what Obama did in 2012; it's whether THIS policy is legal, effective, and moral today. Courts, inspectors general, and congressional oversight exist to judge current conduct on its merits — not to run interference with decade-old grievances.

The Stab

You're not arguing the policy is good. You're arguing someone else was bad too. That's not a standard — that's a tantrum.

Sources