Back to Rebuttal Desk
ImmigrationEconomymediumimmigrants-dont-pay-taxes
“Illegal immigrants don't pay taxes — they drain the system!”
What You Say
Undocumented immigrants pay billions in payroll, sales, and property taxes — often without receiving benefits. Cato Institute research finds immigrants commit fewer crimes and contribute net-positive to Social Security via taxes on invalid SSNs. The 'drain' narrative ignores IRS ITIN filers and state/local tax revenue.
The Stab
They pay into Social Security they'll never collect.
Sources
Related Claims