Back to Rebuttal Desk
Foreign Policymediumnato-obsolete-deadbeat
“NATO is obsolete! Europe doesn't pay their fair share!”
What You Say
NATO's Article 5 has only been invoked once — for the United States after 9/11. European allies increased defense spending after Russia invaded Ukraine, and U.S. troop deployments in Europe are a fraction of Cold War levels. Calling allies deadbeats while taking their intelligence support and basing rights is negotiation theater, not strategy.
The Stab
You want allies to pay more while threatening to abandon them. Pick one.
Sources